Quantcast
Xbox 360 Playstation 3 Nintendo Wii iPhone Video Game Reviews iPhone App Search Playstation Portable Computer PC Games Playstation 2 Games Gear and Accessories for Games Nintendo DS  
Archives Video Media Articles Games Cheats Files Forums

   GENERAL
  Community
  Upcoming Releases
  Latest Releases
  Video Game List
  Game Reviews
  Weekly Game Giveaways!
  Inside The Games
  Previews
  iPhone App Search
   Weekly Features
  Good, Bad and Shipping
  BitMaps
  Rumor Killers
  The Bargain Bin
  Very British Gamer
   PodCasts
  Game On
  Big Red Potion
  Game Zombie TV
   SECTIONS
  Downloads
  Gamer Blogs
  Videos
  Game Cheats
  Top 10 Games
  Screenshots
   WEBSITE
  TGR Staff
  Write With Us
  Advertising Information
  Submit Gaming News
  Submit a Review
  Submit Content
  Video Game Advertising
   Video Game Industry
  Resources
  Video Game Industry Events
  Features and Opinion
  Video Game Company List
Affiliated with:
GameZone.com

Friends:

360 sync


360 Voice

iPhone Sites

iPhone App Index

iPhone App Reviews
Game Reviews Index » Articles Send this page to a friend
Killzone 2: Curse of the Review Score
Posted by Paul Delamore, 310 days ago


I, like many of you, have been guilty of a heinous crime. It’s one that I am ashamed of, but I hope you understand:

I neglected to read a review and looked at the score.

I know, I know…the guilt has been punishment enough, and I hope never to do it again -- but I will. How can I not? How can you not? A score is there to help us -- an exclusive summary for the busy gamer. We should be able to look at the review score guidelines for a website and, in the future, judge a game by the score that website deems it is worth. Right?

Hell no. But in these days of Metacritic and Game Rankings, how can we avoid this lethargy within our ranks?

To answer this, we have to look at a different aspect of gaming culture: Fannboisaurus Rex. The fanboy came, saw, and conquered by multiplying. It slipped into gamers’ ears while they became absorbed by their Nintendos, Xboxes, and PlayStations before burrowing its way into their brains and affecting their tolerance and judgement…oh, and their patience too. Ever since the console war of the current generation kicked off, we have seen the fanboy grow. They demand perfect ‘10/10’ scores for their exclusive games and laugh when the rival console lands an ‘8/10’ triple-A title.

As a result, the actual journalism part of game journalism becomes less relevant and those numbers at the end of a review become oh so important. We only need to look at Killzone 2 to understand the immense pressure gaming writers suffer in choosing a score for the game. They can compliment it all the way through their review and have a legitimate reason for its 8/10 – but that’s not enough for the fanboys. They erupt, lava flows and it leaves the rivals to roast the game from their pedestal. Extinction of the Fannboisaurus Rex would be humane.


Rating: 4.0, votes: 8
 
Comments
Rules
1. No cursing or swear words: Use proper language to express yourself.
2. No flooding or spamming the comment system, abuse will result in a ban.

You may not post comments as a guest. Please register or login to your account.
  #1 Feb 7, 2009 21:01:37 310 days ago
JonahFalcon
1 Comments

Suppose you’re given a major release by a publisher, who says they’re going to allow you to post the review pre-release, give you major hittage.

You review the game and find it to be an okay game, worthy of a 7 or 8. How easy would it be to just nudge that score to a 9 to please the publisher, so they’ll buy more ad space and give you more hot releases to publish reviews early for?

It already happens in the movie and book industry. All. The. Time.


 


Video Game Reviews Twitter
Weekly Video Game Podcasts
Inside The Games

Game Reviews | Weekly Contests | Submit News | Contact | Pages | Blogs | Forums | Video Game Reviews | Video | RSS | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

iphone game
The Game Reviews Picks of the Month: Halo Wars | Killzone 2 | Street Fighter 4 | Resident Evil 5 | Tom Clancy's HAWX